If you stop paying next year, what happens to your quote history?
Question C2 of the twelve. Lock-in is rarely about the software. Software can be replaced in a quarter. It is about the three years of quotes, prices and outcomes that cannot be replaced at all.
This article goes deeper than the sheet. What actually leaves with you, row by row. The four clauses that decide the exit. And a test you can run in week two of a pilot, rather than on your way out.
If you stop paying, your quote history is the part you cannot rebuild. A good vendor says you keep it, shows you the export and names the format. Test that export in week two of a pilot, not at the end. This article explains the exit. It is not legal advice.
Why is the history the thing that locks you in?
Software is easy to leave. History is not.
You can move a quoting product in a quarter. Your pricing desk will complain for six weeks and then stop. What you cannot move in a quarter is the history. Three years of what you quoted, who won it, at what price, and what your agent charged you underneath.
Picture the Tuesday morning. A customer asks for the same lane they shipped in March. Your pricing exec wants two facts before she answers: what you charged that customer last time, and whether you won it. If both facts sit behind a login you no longer have, she is quoting a stranger. She pads the number to be safe, or she loses the enquiry to somebody who did not have to guess.
The same history is what makes any suggested price worth reading. A product that proposes a number from what that customer paid before is only as good as the record behind it. Take the record away and your next product starts from nothing on the day you most need it to be clever.
So C2 is an operational question wearing a legal coat. The contract is only where the answer gets written down. What you are really asking is whether you could still price your own repeat business the month after you left.
- 01Give notice in writingDated, before renewal, asking for the export.
- 02Export while it is liveThe login and the clock are still yours.
- 03Open the file yourselfIn a spreadsheet, on your own machine.
- 04Check what came outLanes, dates, customers, charges, outcomes.
- 05Price one real enquiryA repeat lane, from the export alone.
- 06Ask for deletionIn writing, with confirmation when it is done.
- GATEYou decideWhether the exit is real, before you renew.
What actually leaves with you, and what does not?
Ask for the list row by row. “All your data” is not a list, and the gaps are always in the same places.
| What you built | Usually in the export | Ask for it by name |
|---|---|---|
| Quotes you sent | The quote and its charge lines | Every version, and the date each one went out |
| The outcome | Won or lost, where somebody recorded it | The reason, and who you lost it to when you noted that |
| Customer price history | Per quote, if you can join it up yourself | A per-customer, per-lane view you can sort |
| Rate cards you uploaded | The original files, sometimes | The parsed lines, not only the PDFs you gave them |
| Agent replies | Rarely | The message and the attachment, tied to the enquiry |
| Threads and where they were filed | Rarely | At least the link between a conversation and a job |
| Tasks and approvals | Sometimes | Who approved what, and when |
| Rules, margins and settings | Almost never | A written copy, so you can rebuild them elsewhere |
- Quotes you sent
- Usually in the export
- The quote and its charge lines
- Ask for it by name
- Every version, and the date each one went out
- The outcome
- Usually in the export
- Won or lost, where somebody recorded it
- Ask for it by name
- The reason, and who you lost it to when you noted that
- Customer price history
- Usually in the export
- Per quote, if you can join it up yourself
- Ask for it by name
- A per-customer, per-lane view you can sort
- Rate cards you uploaded
- Usually in the export
- The original files, sometimes
- Ask for it by name
- The parsed lines, not only the PDFs you gave them
- Agent replies
- Usually in the export
- Rarely
- Ask for it by name
- The message and the attachment, tied to the enquiry
- Threads and where they were filed
- Usually in the export
- Rarely
- Ask for it by name
- At least the link between a conversation and a job
- Tasks and approvals
- Usually in the export
- Sometimes
- Ask for it by name
- Who approved what, and when
- Rules, margins and settings
- Usually in the export
- Almost never
- Ask for it by name
- A written copy, so you can rebuild them elsewhere
Read the third column again. It is the difference between an export and a photograph of one.
Two rows on that list are the ones people discover late. Attachments are where exports go thin, because they are large and awkward to package. Configuration is where exports usually stop altogether. The margin rules and routing you built are, in the supplier’s view, settings of their product rather than your data. Neither position is outrageous. Both are worth knowing in March rather than in December.
An export is only real if a pricing exec can answer a live customer question from it. On her own machine. Without logging into anything you no longer pay for.
Which four clauses decide the exit?
Four, and the first one is where most exits go wrong.
One. The window
Ask when the clock starts. The date you give notice, the last day of service, or the day an invoice went unpaid are three very different answers. Ask whether the account stays readable while the window runs, because an export right on a suspended login is not a right.
Two. The format
“A suitable format” is not a format. Ask for the file type by name and the fields it carries, using the table above as your list. A supplier who has done this before will tell you what is in the file without checking.
Three. The deletion
Ask what is deleted, how long it takes, whether backups are included and whether you get written confirmation. The European regulation already requires a processor contract to make them delete or return all the personal data after the end of the services, at the controller's choice (Article 28 of the General Data Protection Regulation). That rule reaches the contacts in your customer list. It does not reach your rate history, so the deletion of that has to be a term you asked for.
Four. What survives
Some clauses outlive the contract. Find out whether your export right is one of them, and what happens to it if the company is sold. This is the clause the dodge question on the sheet is aimed at.
One recent development is worth knowing about because it gives you language to borrow. The European Data Act has applied since 12 September 2025 and covers switching between data processing services. The Commission’s own page says “all providers are required to remove obstacles that their customers may face when they want to switch to another provider or use several services at the same time”, and that the regulation “will also entirely remove switching charges, including charges for data egress (i.e. charges for data transit), from 12 January 2027”. Until then, providers may still charge for the costs of switching. Whether your supplier sits inside its scope is a question for your lawyer. The useful part is the standard it describes, which you can ask for in your own contract today.
What did the vendor just describe?
The strongest answer. Run it once during the pilot and once a quarter afterwards, and the question stops mattering.
Workable, if the clock starts on a date you control and the account stays readable while it runs. Get both in writing.
Not an exit. Price the cost of rebuilding three years of history, then decide whether you still want the product.
What are the traps?
Four, and every one of them sounds fine when it is said out loud.
Trap one. A promise instead of a term
“We would never do that” describes a person, and the sheet marks it as a warning sign for good reason. People move on. Companies change hands. The contract stays. Ask for the sentence, not the sentiment.
Trap two. A photograph of your history
A folder of quote PDFs is a filing cabinet, not a history. Ask for the file a spreadsheet opens, with the lane, the date, the customer, the charge lines and the outcome in columns somebody can sort.
Trap three. The clock that starts at the wrong moment
Thirty days is generous or useless depending on when it begins and whether you can still log in. A window that opens on the day service ends, on an account that has already been closed, is a window onto nothing.
Trap four. The export nobody has ever run
Plenty of exports exist in a document and nowhere else. Ask when it was last run for a company your size. Ask how long it took. Ask whether you can watch one, even with another company’s data removed.
How do you test the exit before you need it?
Run it in week two of the pilot. Nobody tests an exit in the last week and enjoys the result.
The test takes an afternoon.
- 01Export everything the pilot has produced. Note who pressed the button and how long it took.
- 02Open the file on your own machine, in whatever your pricing desk actually uses.
- 03Count the columns against the table above and write down what is missing.
- 04Give a pricing exec one real repeat enquiry and the export, and nothing else. See whether she can price it.
- 05Ask for the test file to be deleted, and see whether a confirmation arrives.
Then write down what you found, in three lines, while it is fresh. A month later you will remember that it went fine and none of the detail that made it fine.
| What to record | What belongs in it |
|---|---|
| The window | When the export right starts, when it ends, and whether the account still opens. |
| The file | The format, the fields it carries, and the date you watched it run. |
| The survival | What happens to the right if the company is sold, and where that is written. |
- The window
- What belongs in it
- When the export right starts, when it ends, and whether the account still opens.
- The file
- What belongs in it
- The format, the fields it carries, and the date you watched it run.
- The survival
- What belongs in it
- What happens to the right if the company is sold, and where that is written.
Do not negotiate the exit at the exit. Put the export right, the named format and the window into the order form before you sign, then run the export once during the pilot. A supplier who agrees in writing and demonstrates it once has answered C2 better than any assurance can.
What if they are acquired, or they shut down?
This is the dodge question from the sheet, and it is not rude. It is the ordinary future.
Acquisition is the common case rather than the disaster. Products get bought. What follows is a harmonisation of terms at the next renewal, and that is where an export right nobody wrote down quietly disappears. A right written into your order form travels with the contract. An assurance from a founder does not.
Closure is the harder one, and three plain questions cover it. Who holds the data. Who pays the hosting bill in that scenario. Whether anybody outside the company can hand you a copy. A standing export you run yourself answers all three without anybody having to predict the future.
That is the honest conclusion of this whole page. Whatever the contract says, take a copy every quarter and keep it where you keep your other records. It costs an hour. It ends the argument before it starts, and it works no matter who owns the supplier next year.
Put C2 to the software you have now, too. If it went dark this month, what could you still price from? Most forwarders find the answer is a shared drive and one person’s memory. That is worth fixing whether or not you buy anything, and it is a fair thing to put to us as well.
Common questions
Is a read-only account after we stop paying good enough?
No. Read-only is access to their copy, not possession of yours, and it usually ends when the archive is retired. If it is all that is on offer, ask three things. How long it lasts, what it costs, and whether you can still get a file out of it. Then price the risk properly.
How often should we take an export?
Once a quarter, once before every renewal, and once before any conversation about price. Quarterly is often enough that the gap never hurts, and rare enough that nobody minds doing it.
Does data-protection law get my quote history back?
No. Those rules reach the contact details of the people you deal with. They say nothing about a rate card, a margin or a win record. Your quote history comes back because you asked for it in the order form, or it does not come back.
What if our data sits in another country?
Ask where it sits today, who the sub-processors are, and what notice you get if either changes. Then ask the same question about the export: which of those parties has to cooperate for you to receive a file.
- FreighAI Playground — programme outline and the twelve-question checklist (internal document; question C2 and its four aids)verified 2026-09-03
- European Commission — Data Act explained: applies since 12 September 2025; “all providers are required to remove obstacles that their customers may face when they want to switch to another provider or use several services at the same time”; switching charges, including data egress, removed entirely “from 12 January 2027”verified 2026-09-03
- EUR-Lex summary — rules on fair access to and use of data (Data Act): entered into force on 11 January 2024, applies from 12 September 2025, and aims at facilitating switching between data-processing service providersverified 2026-09-03
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679, Article 28(3) — the processor contract must bind them to delete or return all the personal data after the end of the services, at the controller's choiceverified 2026-09-03
Ask C2 while you still have the upper hand
The week you sign is the only week anybody is motivated to write your exit down. Ask for the format, the window and the survival clause now, run the export during the pilot, and keep a quarterly copy whatever happens next.